Picture supply: Getty Photos
Beleaguered fast-fashion retailer Boohoo Group (LSE:DEBS) — which now trades as Debenhams — has a grim historical past of gloomy earnings studies. Nonetheless, first-half outcomes launched yesterday (27 November) acquired an ecstatic market response, with the Boohoo share value leaping from 12p to 22.50p as I write.
There are good causes for optimism. Aggressive cost-cutting measures are beginning to bear fruit. What’s extra, the AIM-listed agency’s transition to a market mannequin throughout all divisions seems to be the suitable technique.
However are these components sufficient to maintain a permanent share value restoration amid bitter company governance tensions and continued income declines? I’m not so positive. Right here’s why.
Turnaround triumphs
Let’s begin with the undeniably spectacular highlights. Publish-tax statutory losses have nearly been eradicated, falling from £126.7m to only £3.4m.
Furthermore, underlying working revenue turned constructive, coming in at £2m following a £9m loss within the earlier interval. And the stability sheet‘s additionally in higher form, because of a £32m internet debt discount to £111m. These are vital achievements.
The revival’s being pushed by CEO Dan Finley’s shift to a marketplace-led mannequin. This new framework now represents 32% of the group’s gross merchandise worth – up from 19% a yr earlier.
In essence, the intention is to shift the corporate from a conventional on-line retail construction, the place the enterprise holds and sells its personal stock, to a platform that connects third-party sellers with clients, like Amazon does. The board punchily describes this as “stock-lite, capital-lite, margin-rich and extremely money generative“.
With market companions doubling to twenty,000 in a yr, development is gathering tempo. Promisingly, all 5 group manufacturers — Boohoo, boohooMAN, PrettyLittleThing, Karen Millen, and Debenhams — at the moment are marketplace-enabled with proprietary know-how.
Flies within the ointment
Regardless of encouraging progress, I believe the Boohoo share value may in the end come below additional strain. Let’s not neglect we’re nonetheless speaking a couple of loss-making enterprise right here. Worryingly, income declined by 23% to £297m. The corporate’s not out of the woods but.
Moreover, the group is locked in a bitter feud with its largest shareholder. Mike Ashley’s Frasers Group owns practically 30% of Boohoo shares. In an unorthodox transfer, Boohoo Group has bypassed buyers by not placing a brand new administration incentive plan to a shareholder vote. CEO Dan Finley stands to obtain a whopping £150m payout if he can elevate the valuation to £4.2bn.
This comes after Ashley demanded the suspension of founder and govt vice chair Mahmud Kamani from the board only a few months in the past. He additionally opposed the Debenhams rebranding earlier this yr.
Because the dispute trundles on, there’s a danger this might all finish in tears for Boohoo if Ashley chooses to instigate shareholder rebellions, disrupt future strategic strikes, launch a hostile takeover bid, or pursue litigation. These dangers shouldn’t be ignored calmly, as any Newcastle United supporter can attest to.
The underside line
I’m happy to see Boohoo Group taking steps in the suitable route. The profitable execution of key strategic objectives ought to be recommended. Nonetheless, half-year earnings had been hardly flawless, and acute company governance dangers ought to be on the forefront of potential buyers’ minds.
There’s much more to love about Boohoo shares at the moment, however not sufficient for me to take a position at current.
