Picture supply: Getty Pictures
In terms of defensive FTSE 100 shares, Diageo (LSE: DGE) has lengthy been seen as a reliable selection. The agency’s the world’s largest premium spirits producer, behind family names together with Guinness, Johnnie Walker, Smirnoff and Tanqueray. With a broad world footprint and iconic model portfolio, Diageo’s traditionally supplied regular returns for long-term shareholders.
However the previous few years have been sobering.
Worth efficiency that’s exhausting to abdomen
Over the previous 12 months, the inventory’s dropped by 25%, and is down 33% over 5 years. Buying and selling as we speak at £18.95, it’s shortly approaching its 10-year low of round £16, final seen in August 2015. That’s a worrying pattern, particularly for traders like myself who had excessive hopes of this defensive stalwart defending their capital throughout risky markets.
Valuation metrics don’t supply a transparent sign both. Its price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 15 appears to be like engaging for a significant blue-chip inventory, however its price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of two.7 tells a extra cautious story. Income’s declined by 3.88% 12 months on 12 months, whereas diluted earnings per share have fallen by 11.33%.
These figures hardly encourage confidence.
The dividend’s holding – however for the way lengthy?
Diageo nonetheless pays a decent 4.2% dividend yield, which gives some consolation. Nonetheless, dividend development’s been paused — a big change for earnings traders who’ve come to anticipate constant hikes.
Extra regarding is the corporate’s £17bn debt burden, which is nearly twice its fairness base. Whereas an organization of this scale’s unlikely to default, this stage of leverage makes it weak to increased rates of interest and limits its strategic flexibility.
When firms want money for debt, dividends typically see the axe first.
What’s going incorrect – and is there a path to restoration?
Diageo’s been hit by a mixture of macroeconomic challenges and shifting habits. Excessive inflation has tightened client budgets, with many patrons now choosing cheaper manufacturers or prioritising necessities over pointless luxuries. And amongst youthful generations, alcohol consumption’s declining, with an increasing number of Gen Z’ers favouring low- or no-alcohol options.
Rivals resembling Pernod Ricard are dealing with related points, however Diageo’s efficiency has been weaker in sure key markets, notably Latin America, the place gross sales have slumped.
To its credit score, it’s actively attempting to reshape its portfolio, investing in non-alcoholic manufacturers and experimenting with premium ready-to-drink choices. However there’s no telling but if this will probably be sufficient to reverse the present state of affairs.
Hanging on to hope
Regardless of the current struggles, I nonetheless consider alcohol’s a resilient class. It’s been part of human tradition for hundreds of years and I merely can’t think about it might vanish in a single day. Diageo nonetheless boasts a wholesome internet margin of 19% and a formidable return on fairness (ROE) of 35%, suggesting the core enterprise stays sturdy.
If the corporate can streamline operations and regain momentum in underperforming areas, a restoration’s doable. However with debt excessive and earnings beneath strain, I gained’t be shopping for extra shares till I see clearer indicators of a turnaround. For now, I’ll maintain holding – but when it drops under £16, I’ll contemplate chopping my losses.
