Now that’s a surprise! The Lloyds share price went up despite disappointing results

Effectively, I wasn’t anticipating that. The Lloyds Banking Group (LSE:LLOY) share worth closed 4.9% increased 20 February, after the financial institution launched its 2024 outcomes.

At one level, its inventory was up 7.6%, having set a brand new 52-week excessive of 67.6p.

And but the financial institution failed to fulfill analysts’ expectations on quite a few key measures. In these circumstances, I’d usually count on the group’s worth to go down. As an alternative, traders collectively determined that its market-cap needs to be over £1.15bn increased.

Decrease-than-expected income

For instance, the consensus of analysts was for post-tax earnings of £4.64bn. The financial institution missed this by £161m (3.5%). Additionally, at 12.3%, its return on capital employed was 0.3 share factors decrease than forecast.

Nonetheless, my largest shock is that traders appeared to disregard the rise within the quantity put aside to cowl fines and compensation arising from the Monetary Conduct Authority’s (FCA) investigation into the alleged misselling of automobile finance.

Beforehand, the financial institution had estimated that it may need to pay £450m. This has now been elevated by an extra £700m, to £1.5bn. Nonetheless, it’s nonetheless decrease than the £4.2bn (or 6.9p a share) that one analyst reckons it’ll value.

As occasions have unfolded, we’ve seen how delicate the financial institution’s share worth has been to numerous court docket judgements, FCA bulletins and media stories. With disappointing income and a rise within the motor finance provision, I used to be anticipating a big correction within the share worth, particularly because it’s carried out so strongly in latest months.

Egg on my face

However I used to be incorrect. Nonetheless, on nearer inspection, it’s straightforward to see why traders reacted so positively. Regardless of the bottom fee being minimize, it managed to report a internet curiosity margin of two.95%, which was consistent with ‘knowledgeable’ predictions.

Additionally, the financial institution’s elevated its dividend. The payout for 2024 will now be 3.17p. This beat market expectations by 2.6%. Even with the post-results leap within the share worth, the inventory’s yielding 4.8%. Additionally, it’s introduced one other £1.7bn of buybacks.

Nonetheless, I imagine future dividends and share buybacks might come beneath risk if the motor finance provision needs to be elevated additional. When there’s a have to protect money, these are straightforward targets.

However I feel the Lloyds share worth isn’t the cut price it as soon as was. It has a price-to-book (PTB) ratio of 0.88. On paper, this implies the inventory’s low-cost. Nonetheless, in response to McKinsey & Firm, the common PTB ratio of 1,500 listed banks is 0.9, the bottom of all sectors.

And its shares now commerce on a a number of of 10.5 occasions its 2024 earnings. With the entire FTSE 100’s banks now reporting their 2024 outcomes, it’s attainable to compile a league desk of price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios, and Lloyds is on the backside.

I imagine this displays the latest share worth rally moderately than traders score the financial institution extra extremely than the others. Lloyds is sort of completely reliant on the home economic system, and with the UK struggling to develop, I worry the financial institution’s future earnings could disappoint traders. Additionally, I’ve no thought what the ultimate invoice is perhaps as soon as the FCA completes its investigation.

For these causes, I’m not going to take a position.